ORIGINAL: USAF_hunter
Yah I give thanks, to my grandfather and father for teaching me to hunt and fish. I also don't believe in the use of dogs for any part of deer hunting. This is just my opinion. In my expirience I have never seen a lung shot deer survive.
Back on subject, your brother in law needs to take more resonsibility in the harvesting of animals or find a new hobby.
Using a tracking dog to find downed deer that would otherwise go unrecovered is not only moral but ethical. Your experience doesn't cover all the 100's of thousands of deer that are shot every year. When it comes to nature, especially whitetails, I don't take anything for granted.