Rob/PA asked me the other day what the buck I shot last week scored (the bull). I may never know....and it doesn't matter. He likely wouldn't outscore my '06 buck.
I don't see anything wrong with scoring deer....and I LOVE guessing the scores. I also think that you could get three very different scores from 3 different people. I've seen some deer in the contest that amazed me (but the OTHER way

).