I too am new to shotgun deer hunting, however I own a pardner pump and it shoots the birds just fine. It is equivilent to the 870 in every aspect I can find. I have shot both models and was just as satisfied with either's performance. I would say save the extra cash and get this gun. It is just as functional as the 870 and uses the same acessories; chokes, barrels, etc. Either way you go, you are getting a heck of a gun. I have lots of fun with mine.