If you have a stand that nobody likes to hunt because it isn't any good, persuade the new guy to hunt there. When you are showing him the stand, allow him to find the pair of monster sheds that you had planted there earlier.

The funny thing is that when we let our "new guy" in on the joke after the first day, he didn't believe us. He thought we were trying to steal his spot. He hunted that spot faithfully everyday. Not once did he see a deer. He still to this day doesn't believe we were pulling his leg.