Would the G&F Warden issue another tag for your buddy? Under those circumstances, you might ask!
Next time (I always do this), take your dated and signed tag and roll it up tight andhide it somewhere on the animal. I've stuck it in the ear, slid it under the neckskin, etc. This way, if you DO see it and suspect it's yours, you can prive it to the authorities.

The elk Gods will shine on your buddy. So sad.