RE: good deer or another year??
The question I have for you is do you have anything bigger on the wall? If not then I would say he is a good buck to start out with. If you have some racks on the wall then let him go and grow a couple more years. I have 1.5 year old deer with antlers bigger then that but his body looks like a 2.5 year old. It is up to you when you see him.