Well, I thought I was going with the Mucks but I tried some knee highs and was not comfortable with them. So I bought some Irish Setters and they are way too bulky. Maybe I'm wanting the best of both worlds, soft sole boot, not bulky with plenty of insulation to keep my feet warm.

My feet shouldn't be getting cold in the 50's but they do. I dread when it sometimes gets in the teens but I'm still out there! I'll figure out something.