My first impression without looking at any responses was 3.5 115 maybe 120. If you are looking for a book buck, let him go. If you are happy with him and don't have any doubts about him, then take him. It is all up to you bud and no one else.

Here is another reference picture. This an 8 that I shot last year that grossed 128 and some change and netted 124 6/8"