to me, the one on the left looks like it has more mass...maybe just the pics.

really hard to tell....antlers look the same...but they could be twins or same genes...we got a set of twins running around this year that you cannot tell apart at all.

but really, dont look like he grew any?? hard to tell

5 miles is a LONG way as well...their home range is usually less than a mile from what ive read. maybe during the rut they may travel 5 miles...but i dont know about even then...