You just had to throw that kicker in there about the doe!
I would take the doe just to make sure she didn't suffer. Yes deer can live with injuries, but with the arrow sticking out of her it's a different ballgame.

It's funny I just watched a hunting show where Jeff Foxworthy shot a wounded buck to take it out of it's misery (huge gaping hole in front leg). Some people have all the luck and fortune, [:@]this buck was a trophy in my book. Real nice ten point that probably scored in the 130-140 area.