two fox hunters on horses making all kind's of racket yelling and bugeling. All of the sudden the 8 pointer, along with three
Is that any less fair chase than shooting a deer another hunter spooked into your line of sight?
I shot my doe last year 15 minutes after hearing gun shots in the direction she came running from. I would consider that situation and yours to be the same.
Ultimately, the decision is on the guy/gal holding the gun/bow. You have to sleep with yourself at night, not that I would have any touble sleeping after taking the shot you described.