Im not saying that it is the best choice even if Tiffany shoots them. What I am saying if this guy is dead set on his girl shooting mechanicals that rage broadheads or another rear deploying head would be a good choice. Ive seen Tiffany get more penetration on some deer than alot of profesionals do shooting fixed blades. Whats most important is that 2droptine needs to make sure his girl only takes close shots and the deer needs to be broadside.