ORIGINAL: MO_Bowhnter
I use both but usually buy the no scent stuff. I think smelling like nothing is better than smelling like fake dirt, which to us may smell like the real thing but to the whitetails nose, he might be able to pick out that fabricated scent.
And I can't understand that acorn smell...I've broken acorns up and never have smelled that smell that comes in a bottle.
No, kidding about the acorn scent! I'd put that stuff in my coffee it smells so good! Real acorns ,not so much. But I do think the sweet nutty aroma will attract them probably as well as vanilla would,even though no vanilla grows around here!