I've been looking at picking up the New Nikon Monarch 4-16 x 42 w/ BDC and side focus for $420 shipped. However, I just came across a closeout Monarch 5.5-16 x 44 AO w/ BDC reticle. for $289.95. I'll be yote hunting and deer hunting with this scope on a .243 wssm ansd hink he 5.5 might be a little much.

what would you guys do??