Here in PA they did both and you will get mixed opinions.
I'll wager if you get a handful of deer hunters together, you'll get mixed opinions on just about any facet of deer hunting and deer management. I've already been in a room discussing thingswith a few dozen hunters and it's rare to get half to agree on anything, regardless of the topic.
Such pigheadedness and individualityis probably what makes us go out in a driving rain during hunting season, instead of staying indoors and dry, like "normal" people tend to do.