Portage-I know a lot of us up here like the 35 Rem for deer. I used to own a Marlin 336 in 35 Rem but ended up getting rid of it. It isw as you say very well suited for the area but I am just more comfortable and confident with my 45-70.
Growing up I used my Dad's old Rem Model#8 35. That was pretty heavy (which I liked at the time) but I never did take a deer with it as a kid.
I don't think the 35 is thought quite as highly of outside of New England. Not really sure why. I get the impression most hunting out west and other areas tend to be at greater ranges so that may be the reason.