I used buck grub last year.. 1 bag and it never even got touched that I could really tell anyway.. I was shocked... I put it in a great spot that I know their was alot of deer and it was poor... Dont know why... Never used the c'mere deer... Just went back to the stuff nature provides... I used alot of different baits years ago and just never seemed to have a good buck use it, They were at night because I have pics of some giants using it at night but during the day it was does,fawns and 1st and 2nd year bucks.. No mature bucks.. Not to say it cant happen I just never had great luck with big bucks over bait..