In a 3D deer target, I have a Rinehart Broadhead buck target and it is holding up quite well. My brother in law has a Block 4 dot target and when I shot at it the other day, my field tipped arrow almost broke completely through the center dot at 20 yards. I would look at the Rinehart 18-1 target, looks like a good one, and the one I will get next to replace the Block target we are currently using.