ORIGINAL: Bloodsaw

I think what it comes down to is pulls what u can pull with confort, and if it isnt enough to you, slighty take your draw weight up until u can pull what u feel comfy hunting with, if your Putting the shots right where they need to be and think u can take animals cleanly with it ( and its legal ) then thats fine too. All that said this argument was not over what is ethical and what is better and blah blah, i simply said 30 would kill a mature whitetail when it comes down to it.

Now i want to say sumthing about this

"Also, obsidian is MUCH sharper than steel will ever be."

Im no Expert, so im not saying your wrong, because your more than likley right here, but, if you sharpen steel on a diamond Wheel the right way and polish it, its VERY VERY sharp, i mean scary sharp...and is not choppy lookin at all
Most people mess up on the steel and turn the edges over while sharpenin, but its so tiny u cant really see it, and still seems very sharp.
Again "obsidian" may be much sharpen than even the best sharpened steel (?), but steel can bealot sharper than the average shaving sharp. That being said MOST people arent goin through that trouble with their broadheads..

This is not an attack or an agrument, this is just what i have to say