I to like to make mock scrapes, i use ben lee's buck lure. I myself think it works better than tinks , thats just the way i feel about it . But when the pre- rut realy kicks in and i see more scrapes i use ben-lee's doe. It seems like they keep coming back to check on it , but i got to tell you when a old doe catch wind of it she goe's on high alert snorting and stomping her feet makes a circle around the scrape still snorting and stomping her feet it's almost makes you what to laugh your butt off sitting up in your tree stand.