He's a mature deer for sure, guessing him at 4.5 as well. Since Mike is the only one with a chance, it's a win - win. If he tags him that would be awesome and if not, then next year wont come fast enough. It's a great position to be in. Most of us aren't quite as lucky to have an area large enough to ensure a deer like that will survive a season without a lot of luck. I'd take him all day every day.