It dont work that way, evedently your buddies think deer think like humans, " a mature buck isnt going to walk up to a gut pile and think my gosh that was Sally" Ive shot too many deer that have walked up to one that was laying on the ground shot just five to ten minutes earlier. I shot my biggest buck within ten feet from a gut pile, go out and tag your doe and enjoy the solitude from no one else in the woods.