RE: is my buddy slow or is it me
Since you are talking about public land that is going to get pressure anyway, I say go for it. It sounds like you may get a jump on some guys and get to put some meat in your freezer before you have to worry about horns.
As far as gut piles go, I haven't seen a gut pile stay around long enough to spook deer. The foxes and turkey vultures usually have that taken care of in a day.