As for the 'only sell locally' bit, if thats the case, why not put it in the local paper?

Sticken: I understand you put it locally only and I am the one that asked for shipping. I also offered extra $ for your troubles. You agreed. If you truly DIDNT want the hassle, you should have said so from the start.

In response to Brutalattack: If someone offered more than the agreed upon price I should at least have the opportunity to match or better it. Wouldnt you want the same opportunity? As for shipping, the buyer usually pays shipping costs so that excuse is just an excuse.