Some things like religion & politics almost always stir strong feelings among believers on both sides. And both sides have their strong points.

Different areas often have different beliefs ,different regions often come with different circumstances.

My only suggestion to you is not go toa man that has lived and worked his land for years and tell him how you feel he should manage the deer that live on his land.
Buy yourself some land and treat it any way you see fit.Just like the guy who hunts with a Stick bow instead of one ofthe new hyper arrow launching systems he has his reasons.
We all have our own reasons for how, why & with whom we hunt.
Some things are just best left alone. Go hunt the way you want and leave others to do the same,we will all have a better time that way.