Firstly, CONGRATS on the Pro Hunter, she's an awesome rifle!!!

I have a pair of Pro Hunters and one sports a Swarovski which is a bit more than the above mentioned price range but my thumbhole stocked Encore PH is topped with a Nikon 3-9x40mm Omega scope and in my opinion, it's an outstanding muzzleloader optic! The Omega is available in the $250 price range andit'sa great buy in my opinion!

Good luck and good shootin'