Greenhorngal, I apologize for stubby.

Anyway, I would go with the XCR in the .270 caliber but not just the standard caliber, I would go with the .270 caliber in the .270 WSM cartrige. One of the reasons is that based on it's sectional density and balistic coeficient you cannot go wrong from varmint on up to deer and elk. Another reason is it's shorter barrel of 24" vice 26" heavy magnum barrel and lighter weight. Personaly, I own a 7mm Rem Mag but that's because I bought the best deal that I could afford at the time which was a $475 sale on a Ruger M77 MKII stainles synthetic I bought at Bass Pro Shops in September for their hunting sales. It's another good rifle comparable to the Remingtons to check out unless your hubby is set on the Remmy which I can't blame him.

Good luck!