Stubblejumper, cartridges have been argued over campfires and deer camp tables way before these forums ever existed and they will after our bones are dry.

She asked about a couple calibers and a couple different Remingtons. I think the point was she might want to consider the .270wsm. You seem to think it isn't all that great when compared to bigger calibers...then you compare it to the 7mm-08....Hummmmm Lost me on that one.

"outperforms" is the word you stuck on....Now we all know there are many ways to measure "performance" but the only way to narrow it down to a generic level is to look at it's efficiency and efficacy on game. We at least were comparing apples to apples in the magnums. Then you go to the small case gun. I think you just want argue and that is what makes us all freethinkers....however, in this particular thread it is doing this lady no good at all.

Don't mean to offend, but take it easy. Besides, we are all "experts" on here.....right

All that said, do you think she should work with her husband to get the XCR or SPS in .270 or the good ol' 30-06???

Friends,

Dave