RE: locust or tuscarora
I grew up in that area..........spent a lot of summer picnic fishing trips to Tuscarora State Park.
I think they both rent boats. (Tuscarora had canoes, rowboats and paddle boats but can't remember what Locust has?)
Don't recall the pricing but it's not unreasonable.
Anyway Tuscarora is the MUCH nicer park of the 2, larger more scenic water lots of wildwilfe etc.