Well I'll open with a seies of questions in no particular order of importance.

1) How many racked bucks has the hunter taken?
2) How much time can the hunter spend in the woods?
3) What are his hunting skills?
4) What are his hunting areas genetics?
5) Is a bigger buck in a better shooting situation realistic?
6) Does him or his family require deer meat to sustain nutritional requirements?
7) Would this be the hunters best buck to date?
8) Does this deer have a chance at survival to reach genetic potential (as relates to Hunting Pressure)
9) Would the hunter be proud of this buck?
10) Can it be taken cleanly and ethically?