Jason, Make it a nominal fine if you turn it in and a whopper if you don't. Most guys are honest and will comply. They may grumble but I'll bet they get just a wee bit more careful!.

Adult deer, shed bucks, in doe season... same as a button

WVA has the answer to your check station problem... convenience stores get less than a 1$ stipend for checking deer. It's been a few years since I got this fact and the number may not be perfect. They do it to get traffic in and sell coffee, gas, slim jims etc because of it. they look at the deer, count points, check sex and ask what area it was shot in. 60 seconds or less. BTW they love it when a whopper comes in... they sell even more pop and coffee when a crowd forms!