BtBowhunter,I was laid off this year and bow hunted most of the season.I had a chance to shoot a 4pt and a small 6pt. but saw a bigger buck before them but couldn't shoot.I would of shot the 6pt if I didn't have all the time off I did to hunt because I am not a trophy hunter myself.I will not shoot a 60lb.deer even if it is not a button buck.
I like deer meat too much to bring home a deer like that.I think you are right on about the first deer you shoot it should be tagged what it really is a buck.And if the second deer is a buck as you stated then tag it as so and your done.Two deer both bucks in my book how can you complain.Even though you would maybe have a doe tag left some may say well it should be used to shoot a doe it was in the Quota that was set by the PGC but you already shot a button buck with a tag and under the game laws a button buck is a doe not a buck untill he makes it to the next season.