"Call me something of a perfectionist.
The only reason I'm worried about the paper tearing now is because I'm not sure how it will affect my broadheads at longer ranges. If it kicks one way or the other I don't want it affecting penetration at, say, 60 yards. "
60 yards?? Can you guarantee a perfect hit at 60 yards? Maybe a perfect aim, hold and shot execution but the actual hit might be,, somewhat less than perfect if the stars don't align for you