I have to agree with the crowd on this one. With the turkey you are communicating with the bird and trying to get him to do what you want. While there may be some grunting or rattling with deer it is not the one on one communication you get with the turkey (you talk and he answers or vise versa). If you get lucky enough and he comes in gobbling and strutting I guaranty you that it will put a charge in you like nothing else. I get worked up just writing about it.