Would I give it back? No, I wouldn't. A dog I would automatically assume was someone's pet and might shoot it depending because I don't like dogs that people let run wild. They are basically coyotes at that point.A tiger I would shoot no question and then call the game warden (I do not want that thing around my farm sneaking through the corn with my son playing in the yard). If it were an elk I would know that it just escaped from somewhere and I would let it go and call DNR. But a deer... how am I supposed to know that it just broke out of someone's pen? If it had a big tag in its ear I would just think that it was tagged by the DNR to be honest with you. I don't know, it certainly is a weird occurrance.