Not being impressed by Legend, I would go with the Remington. I have had both of those calibers. Both in Number One Ruger single shots. For a big gun now I would take the same rifle in 45-70. Handloaded it is right on the heels of the 458 win mag. I am looking at a used one now at a local gun store. It has a big Leupold target scope mounted on it. I think the guy was into black powder silhoutte shooting.