You know I sit back and snicker when I read these debates, the only way to ever prove which broadhead is better or which arrow is better is to clone about 5-6 thousand goats or sheep, this is to ensure they all are the same, shoot them in the exact same spot with the same bow from the exact same distance every time and you will have some true results to compare, until then we will argue! I do not care what you shoot into it will not accuratley emulate a living animal.

Up until the end of this season I shot a 20 year old bow with 20 year old aluminum arrows, with new broadheads and killed my first deer with one shot. I now have a bow that is far faster than my old one, it has not drawn first blood yet, I may switch to a heavier arrow if the old ones do not group well enough for me, but for now I will stick with aluminum simply because they do fine and are far less expensive.

The Tazman aka Martin Price
Proud father of a Devil Dog