That is the most rediculous thing I have ever read...........I ask open questions here all the time.........and I read each and every reply and lend no greater value to one over another based on what I think of that persons hunting abilities................that is just stupid.

To me this thiking is flawed. When I am seeking advice from people I want expert opinions. That doesn't mean I don't respect everyone else's opinion, but I will put more stock in someone that is experienced rather than a new person. For example, I would have more emphasis on something that Davidmil or Len had to say rather than some of our young teenage members. That not a knock on the young guys, but Len and David have over 200 deer between them easily. To me that makes their opinion a little more valuable.