I agree with you, BUT....then you will have the hunters who will say they don't hunt for antlers, they hunt to feed there family, which is there right to do so, and I have no problem with hunters who do that.

If it's a law, then I just obey it, what more can you do? The deer population, is by most accounts very high in most states, so I don't think Antler hunting vs. Meat hunting effects those numbers to much either way.