here are some I found with a quick search No personal experience with any. I did see the second place featured on Peter Fidducia's Woods & Water and looked like a great place. I don't know if the 3rd has deer, mostly exotics. I have seen the 3rd and 4th places advertised at outdoor shows.

http://www.biggamehuntingny.com/
http://www.hiddenvalleyvacations.com/hunting.html
http://www.coldbrookhunts.com/
http://www.hunt-tioga.com/
http://www.cherryridge.com/
http://www.homesteadhunts.com/