I prefer a drop away, either the dropzone or trophy taker. It is unreal how much more accurate you can be with a drop away. Once you release the arrow it drops down and you can actually flinch a bit and it will still shoot true. It really helps if you do not have perfect form. Plus it saves your fletchings and makes zero noise. I have belly crawled for hours chasing turkeys and antelope with my trophy taker with the with the NAP arrow holder and have yet to have it fall off when putting it to the extreme. Goodluck in making the choice, if you want accuracy go with a drop away.