I am picky on fit and finish, that was my first criteria for a bow, it led me to Excal.. Every Google search I did on what people think about the same question you have asked led me right back to the same bow..
I think the things are under priced, I got to hold a Stryker today, felt OK, but very awkward compared to my Excal at half the price.
I Think in a world where it is difficult to get what you pay for the Excalibur line up is worth every cent. Another thing to consider is the way they back it up, in all the hours of research I found nothing about people not happy with their purchase. Excaliburs customer service is world class.
I say go for it.