The problem with that is, this entire argument is all really based on individual setups and preferences. I prefer a little heavier aluminums over the carbons. I just feel they shoot better for ME out of MY setup. Others have stated that they like carbons with their setup. Its all subjective, yes there is somephysics involved, but most of us don't care about that portion of it, we just want something that shoots well for the money we spend on it and will take down deer.

That being said, I would love to see the Mythbusters do some hunting related myths!