I'm not quite sure of the out come, We all see where the arrow started. Only with enough experience do you realize the dramatic force and mysteries associated with the aftershot. A friend of mine shot a deer similar to the placement on yours...the arrow went through but the fletchings stayed in the spine...The deer after running flat out for about 300yards went to break the arrow off. By doing so he pushed the knock into his lungs breaking the arrow off on the near side dropping him almost instantly. the arrow path in the deer looked almost like the letter z if you were facing him.......that deer was meant for the table, yours might have had a different outcome..Good luck