IN the upper end 1" scopes, you will not be able to tell a lot of difference. Nikon Monarch, Bushnell 4200, Leupold VX III ...etc. You can tell a difference between a 1" scope and a 30 mm scope. The 30 mm scope is better at transmitting ( not gathering ) light. There is some difference ( but not a lot ) in a 40 mm vs a 50 mm in the 1 " scopes, just like there is a difference between the 50 mm and 56 mm in the 30 mm scopes.

But just realize the height you have to mount a 56 mm belled , 30 mm scope. You would have to mount the thing on the highest rings you could find, which will take it out of the normal sight plane along the comb. But some people don't mind that.

I definitely want you to get what you want, butare you wanting the name brands,or doyou want good quality that will get the job done, but where you are not throwing money away. I personally would want the best I could get, but also what falls within the laws of deminishing returns. In other words, could I spend 800.00 and get a set up that is 95 % of what I like best, or should I spend 1600.00 to get 100 % of what I like best. That 5 % cost you double. For that you could buy 2 of the 95 % set up's. But in the end it will be what ever makes you happiest. Only you knows what will truely satisify you.

Good luck in your decision, and God Bless