Hey I am not going to tell you to spend any money that you can't aford to. Some people don't "need" a $400 scope, they just "want" it. Big Difference. As I have said before, it is the "mine is bigger" "mine is better" "mine cost more" mentality. I personally don't think the high dollar scopes are for everyone, especially if it doesn't fit your budget. I currently use a Bushnell sportsman 3-9x40 on my .17 HMR and no problems yet. I also happen to like it a lot. I actually don't have any of the scopes you mentioned, but one of my friends has a Banner on his .243 and he really likes it, so that may be worth looking at. I know before this thread is over at least one person will suggest "save your money blah, blah, blah" but if you don't have it or can't get it easily then get what you can afford. Good Luck.