RE: peep sight vs. hind sight??
You JUST described the difference in night and day to the world, David. I was doing EXACTLY what you were describing by attempting to center each sight pin inside my small peep. I didn't know any better.
When I switched sights....and went with the larger peep.....it just so happened it gave me the DESIRED outcome you also describe. it was HIGHLY enlightening. I no longer have to center each sight pin. It's awesome. Imagine shooting for over a year.......having never shot a bow before.......and then STUMBLING onto this. Yeah....I was pumped.