DougE, It may well be that the calculated kill is accurate enough. I even tend to agree with you that it's close enoughbut I still believe we need a better reporting system for two reasons.

1 By continuing to use a method whereby the majority of hunters ignores the law, it sends the message that the PGC isn't serious about enforcing their own laws. When any government entity simply looks the other way when 60% of the public ignores the law, it breeds disrespect for any of it's laws.

2 Partly because of the phenomenon above, the PGC needs to do anything it can to shore up it's credibility and a better reporting system would be a big step