ORIGINAL: Doubled 150
I'd shoot #1 for sure. He's for sure a 4-1/2 year old, maybe 5-1/2.
Nope, not close.....that's GregH's photo he snapped and passed on this deer because it was not 4.5 or up, Right Greg?
As for me, assuming your strictly talking comparison of animals and not shot position then number 1 was my pick.