First off, setting the types of expectations as you have will eliminate 90% of any of the outfitters out there no matter what state they are located in..... Nobody can guarantee the results you expect to have....
Number one reason is it is ILEGAL in most states!!!
I belong to a hunting club in Southern Illinois, and run it as well...
We see the types of deer you would like to, but there are never any guarantees... and I would never offer one!!!!
This year we had a father son team that havent seen a shooter all year long.... Last year they both saw more shooters than most will see in their lifetime.. They saw 4 Booners!!! So, you cant form an oppinion with a single years experience...
It takes years to develop an educated oppinion of any property... period!!!
Bad experiences with outfitters can be viewed in many lights, and categories... So, break it down, elaborate just a llittle.. PLEASE do not speak harshly of Illinois outfitters in general!!! Theres alot of great operations in Illinois, with some even better hunting, made available through them!!!!
I personally prefer the club hunting atmosphere, it works well for me...
Good luck trying to find what you are looking for though!!!
Paul